Why Lie? Psychological Motivations and How to Handle Deceit

Safety investigations are crucial for understanding the root causes of incidents and preventing future occurrences. However, one of the significant challenges investigators face is the possibility of dishonesty from those involved. Whether a minor omission or a blatant falsehood, dishonesty can obstruct the path to uncovering the truth. Understanding the psychological motivations behind why people lie and learning how to handle these situations is essential for conducting thorough and accurate investigations.

Psychological Motivations Behind Dishonesty

1. Fear of Repercussions

One of the most common reasons individuals lie during safety investigations is the fear of consequences. This could include the fear of losing their job, facing disciplinary action, or damaging their reputation. In high-stakes environments where safety incidents can have severe consequences, the pressure to protect oneself can lead to dishonest behavior.

2. Self-Preservation

Related to fear is the instinctual drive for self-preservation. Employees might worry that admitting a mistake will result in blame or punishment, even if the organization has a no-blame policy. The desire to avoid being seen as incompetent or responsible for an incident can lead to altering or withholding information.

3. Group Loyalty

In tightly-knit teams, loyalty to coworkers can be a powerful motivator for dishonesty. An individual may choose to lie or omit information to protect a colleague or to avoid creating tension within the group. This is particularly common in environments where team cohesion is valued and where there is a strong bond among members.

4. Minimizing the Incident

Sometimes, individuals might downplay the severity of an incident to avoid escalating the situation. They might believe that the incident is not serious enough to warrant full disclosure or that it was a one-off event that doesn’t require intervention. This can lead to incomplete or misleading information being provided.

5. Memory Distortion

It’s important to recognize that not all dishonesty is intentional. Memory is not always reliable, especially in stressful situations. An individual’s recollection of events can be unintentionally distorted, leading to inaccuracies in their account. Over time, these inaccuracies can become more pronounced as the person unconsciously alters the memory to fit their own narrative.

Tips for Detecting and Managing Deceit

1. Create a Safe Environment

To minimize the likelihood of dishonesty, create an environment where employees feel safe to speak openly. Reinforce a culture of transparency and emphasize that the purpose of the investigation is to learn and improve, not to assign blame. Clearly communicate that honesty is valued and that there are no repercussions for admitting mistakes.

2. Ask Open-Ended Questions

Open-ended questions encourage individuals to provide detailed responses rather than yes or no answers. This can help uncover inconsistencies or additional information that may not surface with more direct questioning. For example, instead of asking, “Did you see the incident?” ask, “Can you describe what happened from your perspective?”

3. Pay Attention to Nonverbal Cues

Nonverbal cues, such as body language, tone of voice, and eye contact, can offer insights into whether someone is being truthful. While these cues should not be relied upon exclusively, they can complement verbal information and help identify areas that may require further probing.

4. Cross-Check Information

Whenever possible, corroborate statements with physical evidence, documentation, or other witnesses’ accounts. Cross-checking information helps to identify discrepancies and can be a powerful tool in verifying the accuracy of statements.

5. Follow Up on Inconsistencies

If an inconsistency is detected, address it directly but tactfully. Rather than accusing someone of lying, frame it as a need for clarification: “I noticed that this detail doesn’t quite align with what we’ve seen in the records. Can you help me understand that?”

6. Encourage Honesty Through Empathy

Empathy can go a long way in encouraging honesty. Show understanding and acknowledge the pressures the individual might be feeling. When people feel heard and understood, they are more likely to open up and provide truthful information.

TapRooT® RCA: Psychology of Improvement Track

Discover more insights into the psychology behind Root Cause Analysis (RCA) and enhance your investigative skills at the 2025 Global TapRooT® Summit!

The Psychology of Improvement track will explore various psychological principles, offering practical strategies and tips to elevate your RCA investigations. From understanding human behavior and decision-making to mastering communication techniques, this track empowers investigators with the tools they need to drive continuous improvement.

Get all the details on the Psychology of Improvement best practices track here.

Continue the Discussion on LinkedIn